Studio Ghibli has long been synonymous with magical storytelling, weaving intricate emotions into breathtaking animation. Among its collection of masterpieces lies When Marnie Was There (2014), an adaptation of Joan G. Robinson’s novel of the same name. Unlike Ghibli’s more fantastical tales, this film is a tender exploration of self-discovery, loneliness, and an ethereal friendship that transcends time.
A Melancholic Tale Wrapped in Mystery
The story follows Anna Sasaki, a reserved 12-year-old girl who struggles with asthma and feels emotionally adrift. Sent to a quiet seaside town for the summer to improve her health, Anna grapples with an overwhelming sense of alienation. She sees herself as an outsider, an “invisible” girl who doesn’t belong anywhere. The film masterfully depicts her inner turmoil through moments of solitude, delicate expressions, and a muted color palette that enhances the emotional weight of her isolation.
However, her lonely world takes a dramatic turn when she discovers an abandoned mansion near the salt marshes. There, she meets Marnie—a radiant, golden-haired girl who exudes warmth and mystery. Unlike Anna, Marnie is confident, affectionate, and unreserved, drawing Anna into an unbreakable bond of friendship. Their relationship becomes the heart of the film, weaving between the real and the surreal, blurring the lines between dreams and reality.
Themes of Identity and Belonging
When Marnie Was There excels in its nuanced portrayal of identity and self-worth. Anna struggles with feelings of rejection, exacerbated by the revelation that she is adopted. Her self-doubt manifests in her belief that she is unloved and unwanted, an internal battle that many children experience when grappling with their place in the world. Through Marnie, Anna begins to unravel the layers of her identity, finding comfort and confidence in their bond.
The film delicately addresses childhood trauma, abandonment, and the need for emotional healing. Unlike Ghibli’s more adventure-driven narratives, this story is introspective, mirroring the quiet yet deeply emotional nature of films like Whisper of the Heart (1995) and The Wind Rises (2013). The narrative allows viewers to step into Anna’s shoes, feeling her loneliness but also witnessing her slow transformation.
A Visual Poem of Nostalgia
Visually, When Marnie Was There is a feast for the senses. The coastal town, with its golden fields, serene waters, and towering trees, creates a dreamlike setting that mirrors Anna’s emotional journey. The animation embraces a soft, watercolor-like aesthetic, reminiscent of an old memory—one that is both distant and vivid at the same time. Every frame is carefully composed to evoke longing and nostalgia, reinforcing the film’s themes of the past interwoven with the present.
The mansion itself plays a crucial role in the film’s atmosphere. Its grandeur, contrasted with its apparent abandonment, adds to the mystery surrounding Marnie. The flickering lanterns, the distant echoes of laughter, and the misty salt marshes all contribute to the haunting beauty of the story. It is a place suspended between reality and illusion, much like Anna’s perception of Marnie herself.
A Friendship Beyond Time
One of the most compelling aspects of the film is the ambiguous nature of Marnie’s existence. Is she real? A ghost? A figment of Anna’s imagination? The film never gives a definitive answer, and that’s what makes their friendship so powerful. Their interactions feel intimate and deeply personal, as if they were two halves of the same soul searching for solace in one another.
As the story unfolds, the truth about Marnie’s identity is revealed in a heart-wrenching twist. Marnie is not just a childhood friend but a fragment of Anna’s own past—a connection to her late grandmother. This revelation reshapes everything, turning their ethereal friendship into a deeply personal journey of self-acceptance and familial love. The realization that Anna was never truly alone, that she was loved even when she didn’t believe it, delivers an emotional crescendo that lingers long after the credits roll.
The Power of Subtle Storytelling
Unlike Ghibli’s more action-driven narratives, When Marnie Was There relies on subtle storytelling and character-driven emotion. Director Hiromasa Yonebayashi crafts a film that is quiet yet deeply expressive, allowing silences to speak volumes. Anna’s struggles are not grandiose or exaggerated but deeply human and relatable. The story unfolds gently, almost like a diary entry filled with whispers of the past and reflections on self-worth.
The film’s score, composed by Takatsugu Muramatsu, further enhances its melancholic beauty. The music sways between tender piano melodies and wistful orchestral pieces, reinforcing the film’s dreamlike quality. The hauntingly beautiful song “Fine on the Outside” by Priscilla Ahn serves as the perfect bookend, encapsulating Anna’s loneliness and eventual self-acceptance in just a few verses.
A Farewell to Studio Ghibli’s Golden Era?
At the time of its release, When Marnie Was There was believed to be Studio Ghibli’s final feature film before the studio went on hiatus. This lent the film an even more bittersweet tone, as if it were a quiet farewell to the magic Ghibli had brought to the world. Fortunately, the studio later resumed operations, but When Marnie Was There remains a poignant reminder of Ghibli’s ability to craft deeply personal and emotionally resonant stories.
Conclusion: A Love Letter to the Lost and Found
When Marnie Was There is not just a film about friendship; it is a meditation on loneliness, identity, and the invisible threads that connect us to our past. It resonates with anyone who has ever felt lost, forgotten, or uncertain of their place in the world. Anna’s journey is a quiet yet powerful testament to the idea that love—whether from family, friends, or even those who have passed—never truly disappears.
With its breathtaking animation, heartfelt storytelling, and emotional depth, When Marnie Was There stands as one of Studio Ghibli’s most underappreciated gems. It is a film that doesn’t seek to dazzle with grand adventures but instead whispers a profound truth: sometimes, in the most unexpected ways, we find the love we never knew we had all along.
Watch Cartoons on Kissasian
